Sign in

Spa, MD: The Results-oriented Revolution

Jeffery S. Dover, MD, and Amy Kamin June 2008 issue of Skin Inc. magazine

cosmetic treatment with botox injection

Until recently, the only effective procedure available to the individual wanting appearance enhancement was a face lift. Throughout the past few years, treatments featuring Botox and fillers, as well as laser and light procedures—in conjunction with good skin care—have revolutionized the ability to rejuvenate an aging face.

Statistics

According to a consumer survey by the American Society for Aesthetic Plastic Surgery (ASAPS) of 1,000 American households in 2007, 83% of women and 78% of men would not be embarrassed to undergo cosmetic surgery. This has been a major shift in society’s views toward cosmetic procedures. It has become trendy to openly contemplate procedures with peers, discuss a physician’s techniques and compare results. This trend, however, is occurring in regard to noninvasive, nonsurgical procedures. Recent statistics from the ASAPS reveal that, of 11.4 million procedures performed, 17%—or 1.9 million—were surgical, such as face lifts, eyelid lifts and liposuction, while 83%—or 9.5 million—were nonsurgical, such as the injection of Botox and fillers, and laser and light-based treatments.

Fillers and injectables

While face lifts are surgical procedures associated with anxiety, high cost,and significant recovery periods, filler and Botox treatments are relatively simple, safe, quick, relatively inexpensive and, in many instances, without downtime. Many individuals who would never consider a cosmetic surgical procedure are happy to have a noninvasive procedure. Because of this, the potential pool of candidates has increased dramatically.

At the same time, there have been incredible technological developments related to these noninvasive options. Product and equipment manufacturers have initiated more aggressive marketing approaches, using increasingly sophisticated and expensive direct-to-consumer television and print campaigns.

History

Since the early 1900s, there has been an interest in finding filler substances to enhance the face. The goal was safe and effective tissue augmentation. The early history, however, is full of examples of poor results and terrible reactions.

Injectables’ past begins when German physician Franz Neuber used fat from patients’ arms to fill facial defects in 1893. Foreign substances, such as paraffin and silicone, were used throughout the early-to-mid 1990s. Paraffin induced foreign body reactions and its use as a filler was discontinued. Impure and adulterated silicone has been used quite extensively, resulting in allergic reactions, as well as foreign body responses. In the past few years, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved two different pure medical-grade liquid silicone products for ophthalmic use. Although not yet approved as a filler substance for aesthetic procedures, clinical experience and results from unpublished studies are encouraging.

Neuromodulators

Neuromodulator is the generic name for a group of toxins that selectively block nerve innervations of skeletal muscles. Botulinum exotoxin A, known by the trade name Botox*, is, at this time, the only approved neuromodulator for cosmetic use in the United States. It was accepted by the FDA for cosmetic use in 2002. The year it was introduced, it became the No. 1 injected cosmetic material in use, and one of the most commonly performed cosmetic procedures by physicians and nurses. According to the ASAPS, more than three million people in the United States received a Botox injection in 2006. It is a highly diluted form of neurotoxin that selectively and temporarily paralyzes voluntary skeletal muscle function and it represents only one of a group of neuromodulators. They are designated as botulinum exotoxin A though F. Botox is one of the type A exotoxins. Reloxin**, a different type-A toxin, is presently under review in the United States and is awaiting approval by the FDA, which is expected to happen sometime in late 2008. See Neuromodulator Options for more information about the two types. Myobloc is a type-B botulinum toxin that is not yet approved for cosmetic use, is slightly more painful upon injection and has a shorter-term effect than that of Botox. Other exotoxins are under investigation in the United States and will likely be approved during the next several years.

Fillers

Fillers are biomaterials that can safely and effectively fill creases, lines and areas experiencing volume loss due to facial aging and skin conditions associated with tissue loss. These materials are best classified as either temporary, semi-permanent or permenant, which in turn is defined by the makeup of the substance.

Temporary fillers. Collagen was the first approved filler in the United States and has been in continuous use since the early 1970s. Because it doesn’t last very long, it has been mostly replaced by other longer-lasting, safe and effective fillers, such as hyaluronic acids. Approved collagens are either bovine or human in source. Currently, porcine collagen, derived from pigs, is awaiting imminent FDA approval. See Collagen Options for more information about the various types. The advantage of human and porcine collagen is the very low risk of allergic reactions when compared with bovine collagen, which requires a skin test to rule out allergy.

Hyaluronic acid. Hyaluronic acid, a normal constituent of the dermis, is a complex sugar that makes up a significant portion of the substance of the dermis where collagen and elastin fibers, vessels, nerves and apendageal structures lie. It makes for a versatile filler because allergic reactions are uncommon, it can be used to fill small, large, shallow and deep defects, and it lasts, on average, at least six months. It is effective as soft tissue filler for fine and moderately deep lines, wrinkles and for volume replacement in the face, cheeks and lips. The moldability of the products and natural look of the results make it an appealing filler, and, because allergic reactions are so uncommon, the patient can be treated on the same day as the initial consultation. See Hyaluronic Acid Options for more information about the different available products.

Semi-permanent fillers. Semi-permanent fillers fall between a short, lasting injectable and a permanent injectable, depending on the type of filler and the quantity used. The duration of its effectiveness is somewhere between 6–12+ months. The source of semi-permanent fillers is either natural (purified hyaluronic acid with naturally occurring complex sugar and fat) or synthetic (biodegradable polymer of polylactic acid and hydroxyl apatite). See Semi-permanent Filler Options on Page 62 for more information about the various options available.

Permanent fillers. Permanent fillers have permanent side effects. These materials must be used judiciously and with the right candidates. It is best to first treat these individuals with temporary fillers to be sure they like the result before injecting a permanent filler. The two presently available in the United States are silicone and Artefill. The former is approved for injection in the eye to treat recurrent retinal detachment. When used as a filler, it is considered an off-label use.

Artefill is the first permanent injectable filler approved by the FDA. It consists of synthetic beads of methyl methacrylate in a base of bovine collagen. After injection, the bovine collagen slowly dissipates leaving behind the permanent portion of the product—the synthetic beads of methyl methacrylate. Due to its permanency, it is recommended to do a series of injections for the gradual filling of defects in order to eliminate overcorrection and lumps. Because its source is bovine collagen, allergic reactions are possible. See Permanent Filler Options for more information about the two types.

Techniques

Physicians and nurses must select which material and technique is the best suited for a patient’s particular type of defect, its location, and its desired results. Some want a natural look, while others prefer a more noticeable change. Technique is important in producing the desired results when using injectables. The experience and artistic ability of the physician certainly contribute to satisfying results.

Linear threading. The length of the needle is injected into the wrinkle’s center. The material is injected either as the needle is advanced (anterograde injection) or while it is gently pulled back (retrograde injection); or it can be injected in both directions.

Serial puncture. Multiple punctures are made along the length of the defect, and small amounts of the filler are injected in each site.

Regardless of the technique used, it is best to gently massage the material to ensure even placement of the filler.

Indications, benefits and risks

The general indications for the use of injectables are the patient’s desire to enhance their appearance, whether by eliminating the visible signs of aging or improving the appearance of a tired, aged face. These manifest through fine lines and wrinkles, smile and frown lines, crow’s-feet, nasolabial folds, forehead wrinkles and visible lip aging.

As for benefits, injectables are readily available in physicians’ offices, easy to administer, and results can be quick and effective.

As with anything in the medical field, there can be side effects—most are quite minimal, though in rare cases can be more severe. These can include headache, allergic reactions, swelling, redness, tenderness, bruising, lumpiness, and an incomplete or asymmetrical result.

Combination therapies

The visible signs of aging are due to a combination of factors, including the appearance of lines and wrinkles, volume loss and sagging skin. Therefore, it sometimes becomes essential for physicians and nurses to employ a variety of treatments and techniques to address a patient’s various concerns. For example, it may be recommended to combine Botox, a filler or several fillers, skin care, and laser or light treatments for an individual to accomplish an improvement of the entire canvas of the face instead of a simple spot improvement.

Due to both the extraordinary popularity of injectables and consumers actively driving the industry, manufacturers are clamoring to develop the next blockbuster neuromodulator or filler. Several new neuromodulators await FDA approval, and many new fillers already available in Canada and Europe are under investigation in the United States. Some will be terrific products and others, less so. The injectable arena is a very exciting one in which tremendous developments are awaited with anticipation.

The future

Physicians are looking for ways to get the extreme results of a face lift, but with a more natural look and without an extended recovery time, and the negative side effects of pain and scarring. The options for achieving this will continue to expand because manufacturers are determined to keep supplying more injectables as the demand for them continues to increase. The ability to have remarkable results and client satisfaction without surgery will promote the continued development of materials and nonsurgical procedures that are new, improved and, most importantly, long-lasting.

Related Content

 

Close

Neuromodulator Options

 

Botox*

Reloxin**

Product source

Purified form of botulinum exotoxin A

Purified form of botulinum exotoxin A

Indications

Frown lines between eyes, forehead wrinkles, crow’s-feet, upper lip, lower face and neck

Frown lines between eyes, forehead, crow’s-feet, upper lip, lower neck

Onset

Three days—the peak effect takes place 7–10 days after treatment

2–3 days—the peak effect takes place 7–10 days after treatment

Duration

3–4 months

3–4 months

Treatment protocol

A series of injections every 3–4 months

A series of injections every 3–4 months

Cost

$400–1,500, depending on the number of injections and the amount of material used

$400–1,500, depending on the number of injections and the amount of material used

Benefits

Temporarily paralyzes the muscles that cause lines through negative facial expressions

Temporarily paralyzes the muscles that cause lines through negative facial expressions

Risks

If performed properly, almost none, although bruising, an incomplete effect, brow droop, eyelid droop, lip droop and asymmetry of the effect can occur.

If performed properly, almost none, although bruising, an incomplete effect, brow droop, eyelid droop, lip droop and asymmetry of the effect can occur.

Collagen Options

 

Bovine collagen

Human collagen

Porcine collagen

Product source

Naturally occurring protein from purified cow skin

Naturally occurring protein from lab-grown human foreskin tissue

Porcine (pig) tendons

Indications

Fine and moderately deep lines and creases around eyes and lips; lip and lip edge augmentation; scars

Cosmoderm* for superficial lines, glabellar lines, lip edge; Cosmoplast* for superficial and moderately deep lines and wrinkles, lip edge, lip body and acne scars

Evolence Breeze** for superficial lines, glabellar lines, lip edge, lip body; Evolence** for lip edge, lip body, and superficial and moderately deep lines and acne scars

Duration

2–6 months

2–6 months

Long-lasting temporary—at least 12 months

Treatment protocols

A series of injections every 2–6 months

A series of injections every 3–4 months

One time per year

Cost

$400–800 per syringe

$400–800

$600–1,000 per syringe

Benefits

Versatile, short-acting filler

Versatile, short-acting filler

Versatile, short to mid duration-acting filler

Risks

Allergic reaction, required skin test, bruising, swelling, incomplete correction, asymmetric results

Rare allergic reaction, bruising, swelling, incomplete correction, asymmetric

Rare allergic reaction, bruising, swelling, incomplete correction, asymmetric

Hyaluronic Acid Options

 

Restylane and Perlane*

Juvéderm Ultra and Ultra Plus**

Product source

Genetically engineered streptococci

Hyaluronic acid

Indications

Lips, nasolabial folds, marionette lines, tear trough, adding volume to cheeks

Lips, nasolabial folds, marionette lines, tear trough, adding volume to cheeks

Duration

6+ months

6+ months

Treatment protocols

A series of injections every 4–8 months

A series of injections every 4–8 months

Cost

$600–1,000

$600–1,000

Benefits

Natural looking results; lasts for at least 6 months; Restylane good for finesse areas; Perlane good as an underlay and for volume enhancement

Natural looking results; lasts for at least 6 months; Ultra good for finesse areas; Ultra Plus good as an underlay and for volume enhancement

Risks

1–2 days of redness, swelling, bruising, tenderness

Less redness and swelling than with Restylane and Perlane

Semi-permanent Filler Options

 

Radiesse*

Sculptra**

Autologous fat

Product source

Calcium hydroxyl apatite

Poly-L-lactic acid

Fat harvested from other parts of the body.

Indications

A volume filler for deep nasolabial folds, marionette lines, and hollow cheeks.

A volume filler for deep nasolabial folds, marionette lines, and hollow cheeks.

A volume filler for deep nasolabial folds, marionette lines and fat loss related to aging

Duration

12–18 months after a single treatment; if a touch-up treatment is provided, results are even better and duration is longer

1–2 years after a series of between 3–6 treatments

Six months to life-long; results are best and effect is longer if one or two touch-ups take place

Treatment protocols

Every 12–18 months

May need touch-ups

May need touch-ups; varied by individual

Cost

$800–2,000 per treatment

$800–2,000 per treatment

$1,000–4,500

Benefits

Allergic reactions are rare, and results are long-lasting.

Allergic reactions are rare, and results are long-lasting.

No possibility of allergic reaction, ubiquitous material, natural appearance

Risks

Swelling, redness, bruising and lumping

Redness, swelling, bruising and lumping; requires a series of treatments to obtain the desired effect

Redness, swelling and bruising

Permanent Fillers Options

 

Artefill*

Silicone

Product source

Synthetic beads of methyl methacrylate in a base of bovine collagen

Liquid form of the chemical polymer silicone

Indications

Superficial, moderate and deep lines and folds, acne scars, volume loss

Lips, acne scars, sunken cheeks, nasolabial folds and marionette lines

Duration

Permanent

Permanent

Treatment protocols

One treatment with one or two touch-ups provides the best result

Depends on number of sites and amount of correction desired

Cost

$2,500

$500–1,000 per injection

Benefits

Long-lasting benefit; once the desired result is achieved, touch-ups are needed only as the client ages and lines deepen with time

Long-lasting benefit after a series of treatments; once the desired result is achieved, touch-ups are needed only as the client ages and lines deepen with time

Risks

Swelling, redness, bruising and permanent lumps; should not be used in the lips

Swelling, redness, bruising permanent lumps, and the rare possibility of a late foreign body reaction or migration of the material

Next image >

 

Skip

Welcome to the new SkinInc.com!

Delivering the best information on the spa, skin care and wellness industry is our passion, and we’ve worked hard to design a powerful new website that incorporates cutting-edge technology to bring you:

  • Mobile-friendly Design
  • Integrated Sample Request
  • Refreshed Look and Feel
  • Dynamic Content
  • Free Registration

Mobile-friendly Design

Providing a unified experience from mobile to desktop, responsive design allows you to access Skin Inc. content from any device, whether you’re in the treatment room, at home or on the go!

Integrated Sample Request

Visit Featured Product pages to quickly and easily identify new suppliers and request product samples and information.

Dynamic Content

Articles are now linked with relevant products so you can find the products and treatments you need to provide the best results for your clients.

Free Registration

Create your user account to gain unlimited access to Skin Inc.’s unparalleled content.

Enjoy the New SkinInc.com!

Thank you for joining the Skin Inc. community of passionate skin care professionals. We look forward to providing you the best information to enhance your career!